Unstrategic essentialism: material culture and Hawaiian articulations of indigeneity |
| |
Authors: | Adam Mandelman |
| |
Institution: | Department of Geography, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 550 N. Park Street, Madison, WI53706, USA |
| |
Abstract: | Often rendered synonymous with deep historical attachments to particular landscapes, indigenous identities are inseparable from questions of geography. The meeting ground of place and nativeness is fecund with politics. All over the world, claims of indigeneity have become indispensable in struggles over territory, natural resources, and basic political rights in place. This article focuses on both a handful of cases from the secondary literature and empirical research on Hawai′i's Ala Kahakai National Historic Trail. It discusses essentialist expressions of indigeneity around the preservation and interpretation of Native Hawaiian material culture. Engaging with the literature on articulation theory and indigeneity, it suggests that these essentialisms emerge unintentionally rather than strategically. Its central claim is that the materiality of heritage objects, artifacts, sites, and landscapes plays an unnoticed role in shaping discourses around indigenous identity. The article concludes by suggesting that such unstrategic essentialisms pose real political risks for Native Hawaiians and offer suggestions for a more intentional engagement with the essentializing properties of indigenous material culture. |
| |
Keywords: | indigeneity material culture essentialism Hawai′i National Park Service Ala Kahakai |
|
|