Locating the Cannibals: Conquest,North American Ethnohistory,and the Threat of Objectivity |
| |
Authors: | Amy E Den Ouden |
| |
Institution: | 1. akhan@lums.edu.pk |
| |
Abstract: | This essay critiques the claims to political neutrality and academic authority in an approach to ethnohistory that is defined by historian James Axtell as “balanced” and “objective.” Seeking to shed light on the political genealogy of Axtell’s assertion of objectivity, particularly as it is articulated through an evocation of cannibalism, I trace the ways in which power is implicated in Axtell’s theorizing and argue that objective ethnohistory is linked to conquest as an ongoing ideological and material process. I conclude that objective ethnohistory works to both mask and affirm an imperial grounding, most egregiously through a deceptive rhetoric of democratization in the context of which a posited “we” becomes the supreme cannibalizing trope. Finally, I suggest possibilities for a decolonized, politically engaged ethnohistory. |
| |
Keywords: | Conquest Native North America Ethnohistory Objectivity Cannibal Trope |
|
|