EVALUATION OF THE SEISMIC PERFORMANCE OF EXISTING RC BUILDINGS: II. A CASE STUDY FOR REGULAR AND IRREGULAR BUILDINGS

The results of a parametric study are presented, concerned with the evaluation of the structural overstrength, the global ductility and the available behaviour factor of existing reinforced concrete (RC) buildings designed and constructed according to past generations of earthquake resistant design codes in Greece. For the estimation of these parameters, various failure criteria are incorporated in a methodology established to predict the failure mode of such buildings under planar response, as described in detail in a companion publication. A collection of 85 typical building forms is considered. The influence of various parameters is examined, such as the geometry of the structure (number of storeys, bay width etc.), the vertical irregularity, the contribution of the perimeter frame masonry infill walls, the period of construction, the design code and the seismic zone coefficient. The results from inelastic pushover analyses indicate that existing RC buildings exhibit higher overstrength than their contemporary counterparts, but with much reduced ductility capacity. The presence of perimeter infill walls increases considerably their stiffness and lateral resistance, while further reducing their ductility. Fully infilled frames exhibit generally good behaviour, while structures with an open floor exhibit the worst performance by creating a soft storey. Shear failure becomes critical in the buildings with partial height infills. It is also critical for buildings with isolated shear wall cores at the elevator shaft. Out of five different forms of irregularity considered in this study, buildings with column discontinuities in the ground storey exhibit the worst performance. Furthermore, buildings located in the higher seismicity zone are more vulnerable, since the increase of their lateral resistance and ductility capacity is disproportional to the increase in seismic demand.     

Seismic Vulnerability Assessment of Modular Steel Buildings

Contemporary seismic design is based on dissipating earthquake energy through significant inelastic deformations. This study aims at developing an understanding of the inelastic behavior of braced frames of modular steel buildings (MSBs) and assessing their seismic demands and capacities. Incremental dynamic analysis is performed on typical MSB frames. The analysis accounts for their unique detailing requirements. Maximum inter-story drift and peak global roof drift were adopted as critical response parameters. The study revealed significant global seismic capacity and a satisfactory performance at design intensity levels. High concentration of inelasticity due to limited redistribution of internal forces was observed.     

ADVANTAGES AND LIMITATIONS OF ADAPTIVE AND NON-ADAPTIVE FORCE-BASED PUSHOVER PROCEDURES

The recent drive for use of performance based methodologies in design and assessment of structures in seismic areas has significantly increased the demand for the development of reliable nonlinear inelastic static pushover analysis tools. As a result, the recent years have witnessed the introduction of the so-called adaptive pushover methods, which, unlike their conventional pushover counterparts, feature the ability to account for the effect that higher modes of vibration and progressive stiffness degradation might have on the distribution of seismic storey forces. In this paper, the accuracy of these force-based adaptive pushover methods in predicting the horizontal capacity of reinforced concrete buildings is explored, through comparison with results from a large number of nonlinear time-history dynamic analyses. It is concluded that, despite its apparent conceptual superiority, current force-based adaptive pushover features a relatively minor advantage over its traditional non-adaptive equivalent, particularly in what concerns the estimation of deformation patterns of buildings, which are poorly predicted by both types of analysis.     

Robust Period-Independent Ground Motion Selection and Scaling for Effective Seismic Design and Assessment

A period-independent approach for the selection and scaling of ground motion records aimed at reducing demand variability is proposed for seismic response history analysis. The same set of scaled records can be used to study various structures at the same site regardless of their dynamic characteristics. The statistical robustness of the proposed and current approaches is compared through nonlinear inelastic dynamic analyses performed on single-degree-of-freedom systems and multi-story braced frames. The proposed approach leads to consistent response predictions with a limited number of records. This is advantageous for day-to-day structural design or assessment against code hazard-based seismic demand levels.     

SEISMIC RELIABILITY ASSESSMENT OF EXISTING REINFORCED CONCRETE BUILDINGS

Structures designed according to earlier codes with inadequate seismic provisions have not performed satisfactorily during recent earthquakes. The seismic performance of an existing three-storey reinforced concrete building designed according to the 1963 ACI 313-63 is evaluated and compared to the performance of a similar frame designed according to current code provisions. Non-linear static and dynamic analyses of the reinforced concrete frames are conducted. In this study, a probabilistic approach is adopted where a large number of artificially generated ground motion records is used as input motion to the structure. The results of the analysis indicated the probability of various degrees of damage to be expected when the existing frame is subjected to different ground motion levels. This information is useful in the design of the required rehabilitation scheme to provide an identified level of protection.     

ANALYTICAL MODELS FOR BRICK MASONRY INFILLED R/C FRAMES UNDER LATERAL LOADING

Proposed in this paper are two analytical models for predicting the inelastic response of unreinforced brick masonry infills in reinforced concrete frames subjected to mono-tonic and reversed cyclic loading. The first model is based on the traditional diagonal strut concept, while the second one is a simple isoparametric element with shear deformation only. All the essential characteristics of the hysteretic behaviour of the panel, including strength and stiffness degradation, pinching and slippage, are explicitly taken into account. The models are implemented in a general-purpose program for the inelastic time-history analysis of structures, and are used for studying the seismic behaviour of typical multistorey frames with various arrangements of infill panels, including structures with an open ground storey. The results of the analysis are in agreement with both experimentally observed behaviour and with experience regarding seismically damaged buildings.     

Importance of Degrading Behavior for Seismic Performance Evaluation of Simple Structural Systems

This study focuses on effect of degradation characteristics on seismic performance of simple structural systems. Equivalent single degree of freedom systems are used for which the structural characteristics are taken from existing reinforced concrete (RC) frame buildings. Simulation of degrading behavior is achieved by considering actual experimental data. To obtain the seismic response of degrading structural systems, two different approaches are used: inelastic spectral analysis and fragility analysis. According to the results obtained from both approaches, degrading behavior is dominant for mid-rise RC frame buildings as it significantly amplifies seismic demand. Hence, in performance-based assessment approaches, analytical modeling of such degrading structures should be carried out carefully.     

PERFORMANCE-BASED SEISMIC RESPONSE OF FRAME STRUCTURES INCLUDING RESIDUAL DEFORMATIONS. PART II: MULTI-DEGREE OF FREEDOM SYSTEMS

The role of residual deformations when evaluating the performance of multi-storey frame structures subjected to ground motion is investigated in this paper. The limitations of damage indices available in the literature, either based on ductility, energy dissipation or a combination of both, in capturing such a significant aspect of the seismic response of frame structures are discussed. The concept of residual deformations as a critical complementary indicator to cumulative damage, introduced in a companion paper (Part I) for single-degree-of-freedom (SDOF) systems, is herein extended to multi-degree-of-freedom (MDOF) frame systems. The seismic performance of multi-storey frame structures, either representative of new designed or existing structures, is investigated, focusing on the response in terms of residual deformations. Residual deformations are shown to be sensitive to the hysteretic rule adopted, to the system inelastic mechanism as well as to the seismic intensity. The influence of higher modes and P-Δ effects on the final residual deformations is addressed. A combination of maximum drift and residual drift in the format of a performance matrix is used to define the system's global performance levels and is then extended to a framework for an alternative performance-based seismic design and assessment approach.     

Modeling and Seismic Response Analysis of Italian Code-Conforming Single-Storey Steel Buildings

ABSTRACT

This article describes the structural design, nonlinear modeling, and seismic analysis of prototype single-storey non-residential steel buildings made of moment-resisting portal frames in the transverse direction and concentric braces in the longitudinal direction. Various design parameters (building geometry, seismic hazard, foundation soil category) and different modeling assumptions (bare frame model, model including cladding elements, ground motions including vertical accelerations, and modeling uncertainties) were considered to investigate their effects on the simulated seismic performance.     

CALIBRATION OF FORCE REDUCTION FACTORS OF RC BUILDINGS

A comprehensive study is undertaken to assess and calibrate the force reduction factors (R) adopted in modern seismic codes. Refined expressions are employed to calculate the R factors “supply” for 12 buildings of various characteristics represent a wide range of medium-rise RC buildings. The “supply” values are then compared with the “design” and “demand” recommended in the literature. A comprehensive range of response criteria at the member and storey levels, including shear as a failure criterion, alongside a detailed modelling approach and an extensively verified analytical tool are utilised. A rigorous technique is employed to evaluate R factors, including inelastic pushover and incremental dynamic collapse analyses employing eight natural and artificial records. In the light of the information obtained from more than 1500 inelastic analyses, it is concluded that including shear and vertical motion in assessment and calculations of R factors is necessary. Force reduction factors adopted by the design code (Eurocode 8) are over-conservative and can be safely increased, particularly for regular frame structures designed to lower PGA and higher ductility levels.     

Effect of Hysteresis Type on Drift Limit for Global Collapse of Moment Frame Structures Under Seismic Loads

Seismic analyses of 3-, 9-, and 20-story moment resisting frame (MRF) buildings with 5 hysteresis models were conducted. The objectives of the study were to study the effect of the hysteresis type on the global collapse drift limit, seismic demand, and capacity/demand ratio for MRF structures under seismic loads. The results show that strength degradation significantly decreases the global drift limit and the safety of the structure, whereas, the existence of stiffness degradation or pinching has small effect. The results suggest that the global drift limit for a building is not likely to be the collapse limit state (CLS) which will most likely be governed by local collapse.     

Probabilistic Calibration and Experimental Validation of the Seismic Design Criteria for One-Story Concrete Frames

This article investigates the seismic performance of one-story reinforced concrete structures for industrial buildings. To this aim, the seismic response of two structural prototypes, a cast-in-situ monolithic frame and a precast hinged frame, is compared for four different levels of translatory stiffness and seismic capacity. For these structures an incremental nonlinear dynamic analysis is performed within a Monte Carlo probabilistic simulation. The results obtained from the probabilistic analysis prove that precast structures have the same seismic capacity of the corresponding cast-in-situ structures and confirm the overall goodness of the design criteria proposed by Eurocode 8, even if a noteworthy dependency of the actual structural behavior from the prescribed response spectrum is pointed out.

The experimental verification of these theoretical results is searched for by means of pseudodynamic tests on full-scale structures. The results of these tests confirm the overall equivalence of the seismic behavior of precast and cast-in-situ structures. Moreover, two additional prototypes have been designed to investigate the seismic behavior of precast structures with roof elements placed side by side. The results of these further tests show that an effective horizontal diaphragm action can be activated even if the roof elements are not connected among them, and confirm the expected good seismic performance of these precast systems. Finally, the results of the experimental tests are compared with those obtained from nonlinear structural analyses. The good agreement between numerical and experimental results confirms the accuracy of the theoretical model and, with it, the results of the probabilistic investigation.     

MOMENT RESISTING WELDED CONNECTIONS: AN EXTENSIVE REVIEW OF DESIGN PRACTICE AND EXPERIMENTAL RESEARCH IN USA,JAPAN AND EUROPE

Welded connections, widely used in seismic moment resisting frames (MRFs) in USA, Japan and Europe, have been extensively investigated during the 1990s in order to improve their performance under severe earthquakes. In order to correctly evaluate the results of experimental research on welded connections, the differences among the American, Japanese and European current practices in designing the frame structural systems and in detailing the beam-to-column connections should be firstly appraised. In this paper, the major aspects characterising the USA, Japan and Europe design practice in moment resisting welded connections are reported, the differences are underlined and the main issues recently addressed in experimental research are reviewed. Among the several parameters which affect the connection performance, attention is focused on the effect of the beam cross-section size. Thus conclusions are drawn in terms of plastic rotation capacity as dependant on the beam size.     

Performance of Degrading Reinforced Concrete Frame Systems Under the Tohoku and Christchurch Earthquake Sequences

Field investigations after the recent Tohoku and Christchurch earthquakes reported failure of structural systems due to multiple earthquakes. In most failure cases the reported damage was mainly due to dramatic loss of stiffness and strength of structural elements as a result of material deterioration due to repeated earthquake loading. This study aims to investigate the degrading behavior of reinforced concrete frame systems subjected to Tohoku and Christchurch earthquake sequences. Numerical models of RC frames that incorporate damage features are established and inelastic response history analyses are conducted. The results presented in this study indicate that multiple earthquake effects are significant.     

ESTIMATION OF NEAR-SOURCE GROUND MOTION AND SEISMIC BEHAVIOUR OF RC FRAMED STRUCTURES DAMAGED BY THE 1999 ATHENS EARTHQUAKE

On September 7, 1999 an earthquake with magnitude M _W =5.9 occurred close to the city of Athens in Greece. More than 80 buildings collapsed, about 150 deaths and hundreds of injuries were reported. Soon after the event a damage investigation was carried out by two of the authors in the most heavily struck areas. The most serious damages were observed in the northern suburbs of Athens, where reinforced concrete frames and masonry buildings represent the prevalent construction systems. The hysteretic energy demands imposed on RC buildings should have been rather severe considering the structural systems characteristics and the inadequate construction details. However, over-strengths, redundancy and especially the presence of infill walls, provided a significant increase of the seismic capacity and contributed to the survival of many buildings.

The objective of the present work is to reproduce and analyse the response of typical RC frames subjected to the 1999 Athens earthquake in areas where the observed damage was particularly severe but no recordings of the ground motion were available. After a general overview of the seismotectonic environment, seismological data, observed macro-seismic intensities, structural typologies and observed building behaviour, an attempt is made to identify representative excitations in the meizoseismal area. Specifically, the required accelerograms are obtained by modifying available records so as to reproduce a given global energy content and to be consistent with the observed damage. To study the seismic response of RC models, the obtained accelerograms are used to perform nonlinear dynamic analyses.     

Seismic Assessment of a Monumental Building through Nonlinear Analyses of a 3D Solid Model

ABSTRACT

The paper analyzes the static behavior and the seismic vulnerability of the “San Francesco ad Alto” building in Ancona (Italy), which is currently used as a Regional Headquarter of the Marche Region by the Italian Army and was formerly a monastery. The global static structural behavior and the dynamic properties have been evaluated using the Finite Element modeling technique, in which the nonlinear behavior of masonry has been taken into account by proper constitutive laws. The concepts of homogenized material and smeared cracking are used to evaluate the capacity of the monastery to withstand lateral loads together with the expected demands resulting from seismic actions (N2 method), using a nonlinear static analysis (pushover). The comparison of seismic demand and capacity confirms the susceptibility of these types of buildings to extensive damage and collapse, as frequently observed in similar buildings. This paper aims to point out that advanced numerical analyses can offer significant information on the understanding of the actual structural behavior of historical buildings. It is believed that the methodology and the overall conclusions of this case study are valid for many historical monasteries in Europe.     

ANALYSIS,TESTING AND DESIGN OF STEEL ROOF DECK DIAPHRAGMS FOR DUCTILE EARTHQUAKE RESISTANCE

An experimental program was conducted to study the inelastic response of steel roof deck diaphragms for low-rise steel buildings subjected to seismic loading. Tests were performed on 3.6 m×6.1 m diaphragm specimens made of corrugated steel deck panels. The parameters examined were the thickness and configuration of the sheet steel panels, the type and spacing of the fasteners, the applied loading history and the influence of end lap joints. Diaphragms built with screwed side lap fasteners and nailed deck-to-frame connectors exhibited a pinched hysteretic behaviour, but could sustain large inelastic deformation cycles with limited strength degradation. This type of diaphragm construction could be designed to resist earthquake effects in the inelastic range. Higher shear resistance and less pinching was observed for systems that included welded with washer connections. However, their strength decreased rapidly after the peak load was reached, and hence, these systems should be designed for limited inelastic response. Deck systems with button punched side laps and frame welds without washers showed a brittle response and should be designed to remain elastic under severe earthquake motions. The inelastic demand was found to increase when the spacing of the fasteners was reduced. Specimens constructed with an internal overlap joint exhibited extensive warping of the cross section mainly due to the shorter panel length.     

SEISMIC DESIGN AND RESPONSE OF BARE AND MASONRY-INFILLED REINFORCED CONCRETE BUILDINGS. PART I: BARE STRUCTURES

Abstract

Eurocode 8 is applied for the complete design of 26 multi-storey reinforced concrete buildings to study its operationally and compare the implications of trading strength for ductility through designing the same structure for a different Ductility Class. The difference between the conventional full Capacity Design of columns in bending and the relaxed one allowed by Eurocode 8 is quantified, and the implications on the column capacities are examined. About half of the designed buildings, representative of the class of regular frames, are subjected to nonlinear dynamic response analyses to spectrum-compatible motions with intensities up to twice that of the design motion. Nonlinear modeling is very simple, but gives satisfactory agreement with available quasistatic or pseudodynamic test results on full scale structures. Results show that the three Ductility Classes of Eurocode 8 are essentially equivalent in terms of material quantities and seismic performance. Within the limitations of the nonlinear modelling, the response results suggest very satisfactory performance of structures designed to Eurocode 8, even under twice the design motion intensity. Softening of the structure due to concrete cracking and steel yielding significantly reduces the seismic force demands and contributes to the satisfactory performance, despite the increased P — 6 effects. Another important contributor to the good performance is the significant overstrength of the members considered in the analyses with their average as-built properties. Beam overstrength due to the contribution of the slab to flexural capacity is large enough to overcome the effects of the application of the relaxed Capacity Design rule to columns in bending. However, the resulting column plastic hinging does not lead to drift concentrations suggesting formation of storey-sway mechanisms.     

CONCEPT AND DEVELOPMENT OF HYBRID SOLUTIONS FOR SEISMIC RESISTANT BRIDGE SYSTEMS

The development of alternative solutions for precast concrete buildings based on jointed ductile connections has introduced innovative concepts in the design of lateral-load resisting frame and wall systems. Particularly efficient is the hybrid system, where precast elements are connected via post-tensioning techniques and self-centring and energy dissipating properties are adequately combined to achieve the target maximum displacement with negligible residual displacements. In this contribution, the concept of hybrid system is extended to bridges as a viable and efficient solution for an improved seismic performance when compared with monolithic counterparts. Critical discussion on the cyclic behaviour of hybrid systems, highlighting the most significant parameters governing the response, is carried out.

The concept of a flexible seismic design (displacement-based) of hybrid bridge piers and systems is proposed and its reliability confirmed by quasi-static cyclic (push-pull) and nonlinear time-history analyses based on lumped plasticity numerical models.     

Quantification of Linked Column Frame Seismic Performance Factors for Use in Seismic Design

Previous research has proposed the Linked Column Frame (LCF) as a lateral load-resisting system capable of providing rapid return to occupancy for buildings impacted by moderate earthquake events and collapse prevention in very large events. The LCF consists of flexible moment frames (MF) and linked columns (LC), which are closely spaced dual columns interconnected with bolted links. The linked columns (LC) are designed to limit seismic forces and provide energy dissipation through yielding of the links, while preventing damage to the moment frame under certain earthquake hazard levels. The proposed design procedure ensures the links of the linked column yield at a significantly lower story drift than the beams of the moment frame, enabling design of this system for two distinct performance states: rapid repair, where only link damage occurs and quick link replacement is possible; and collapse prevention, where both the linked column and moment frame may be damaged.

Here, the seismic performance factors for the LCF system, including the response modification factor, R, the system over-strength factor, Ω₀, and the deflection amplification factor, C_d, are established following the procedures described in FEMA P695 [2009]. These parameters are necessary for inclusion of the system in the building code. This work describes the development of archetype structures, numerical models of the LCF systems, incremental dynamic analyses, and interpretation of the results. From the results, it is recommended that R, Ω₀, and C_d values of 8, 3, and 5.5 be used for seismic design of the LCF system. A height limit of 35 m (115ft) is recommended at this time as taller LCFs are not considered in this study.