Mid-latitude frequency spread and its association with small scale ionospheric stratifications

A variety of ground based radio techniques have provided new information relating to the nature of mid-latitude F-region irregularities responsible for frequency spreading on ionograms. Firstly, an analysis of ionograms covering a restricted frequency band indicates that frequency spreading is primarily caused by duplicate traces which are often unresolved in group path on standard ionograms. Furthermore, where angle of arrival information is available, the duplicate traces are shown to represent reflections from markedly different directions and the spread in critical frequencies is therefore indicative of a horizontal gradient in the peak electron density over a scale size of the order of many tens of kilometres. Secondly, the individual duplicate traces themselves are shown to comprise quasi-horizontal trace (QHT) segments which are unresolved on conventional ionograms and contribute to the diffuse appearance of spread-F traces on those ionograms. Difficulties in attributing these observations to the widely held view that scattering from small scale structures is the causative mechanism are discussed.     

Small-scale ionospheric structures associated with mid-latitude spread-F

Slant-F traces on ionograms recorded by a modern ionosonde in a sunspot-minimum period have revealed the existence of field-aligned irregularities at times of spread-F occurrence. This appears to be the first investigation in a mid-latitude region around 36° (geomagnetic) to detect these irregularities at F₂-region heights using an ionosonde. Although such traces were observed frequently near sunspot minimum they were seldom recorded for periods close to sunspot maximum. Also, for a specific spread-F event in August 1989, both the ionograms from the modern ionosonde and scintillations of 150 MHz transmissions from a Transit satellite indicate the existence in the ionosphere of periodic structures (period around 11 min). The scintillation recording also included rapidly fading signals indicative of small-scale structures. The satellite had a path close to the magnetic meridian which passed through the recording station (Brisbane, Australia). Because of the enhanced signal fluctuations in the scintillation recording on this occasion it seems likely (with the support of other evidence on the ionograms) that the small-scale structures present were field-aligned.     

The nature of ionospheric spread-F irregularities in mid-latitude regions

Initially, this paper considers earlier experimental results (some of them hitherto unpublished) obtained by making observations on signals returning from mid-latitude spread-F irregularities. These results suggest associations between spread-F irregularities and nighttime travelling ionospheric disturbances. Statistical analyses are then described which investigate the spread-F phenomenon at a number of mid-latitude stations with approximately the same latitudes but distributed over a range of longitudes. An east-west movement of spread-F irregularities is revealed when the occurrence at these stations is considered relative to days of enhanced occurrence at a particular station. All the experimental evidence presented in the paper supports the idea that the appearance of mid-latitude spread-F ionograms results primarily from specular reflections from relatively-large-scale structures which can be imagined as being in fact nighttime travelling ionospheric disturbances. These are, in turn, possibly related to internal gravity waves in the neutral atmosphere. It is suggested that the small-scale ionospheric structures (which are undoubtedly also present) are effective in inhibiting some of the specular reflections thus contributing to the diffuse nature of some records. This idea is quite contrary to the generally-accepted view that the spread-F traces are a direct consequence of scattering from these small-scale structures.     

Small scale stratification of the mid-latitude F-region

lonograms recorded over limited frequency and height ranges have been used to reveal systematic structures on both main and range spread traces for a mid-latitude region. This fine structure has apparently not been reported previously. When disturbances are present ionogram traces are often made up of quasi-horizontal segments, suggesting that the F2-layer consists of stratified regions spaced a few kilometres apart vertically. It is proposed that if in fact stratifications are present, they may be produced by instabilities created by the presence of internal gravity waves. Interference effects on ionogram traces are also reported. These are shown to result from the presence of overlapping traces. The existence of these quasi-horizontal trace segments and interference effects is shown to contribute to the diffuseness of a range spread mid-latitude ionogram. Thus a mid-latitude range spread ionogram often appears diffuse even though the spread may consist primarily of a number of duplicate traces produced by specular reflections from a range of off-vertical angles.     

The global distribution of ionospheric small-scale irregularities from topside sounding data

This paper examines the global distribution of electron density irregularities with scales of the order of several tens to hundreds of meters in the ionosphere by using topside sounder data from the COSMOS-1809 satellite obtained in May–June and December 1987. The diffuse traces of Z-waves on topside ionograms in a frequency band just below the upper hybrid resonance are used for diagnostics. These traces are attributed to the scattering of sounder-generated ordinary and slow extraordinary mode waves.     

spread-F ionospheric irregularities and their relationship to stable auroral red arcs at magnetic mid-latitudes

The signature of the stable auroral red arc (SAR arc) as it appears on ionograms is described. The key features are a very significant increase in the amount of spread-F and a reduction in the maximum plasma density compared with regions just equatorward and poleward of the SAR arc Identification of the SAR arc signature is made by using complementary data from the global auroral imaging instrument on board the Dynamics Explorer-1 satellite.At sunspot minimum there is a positive correlation between the occurrence of spread-F on ionograms from Argentine Islands, Antarctica (65°S, 64°W; L = 2.3) and magnetic activity. In contrast, at sunspot maximum there is a weak negative correlation when the K magnetic index is less than 6. but a significant increase in spread-F occurrence at K ⩾ 6. Detailed study of ionograms shows that there are two distinct regions where considerable spread-F is observed. These are the region where SAR arcs occur and the poleward edge of the mid-latitude ionospheric trough. They are separated by a region associated with the trough minimum, where comparatively little spread-F is seen. It is suggested that the movement of these features to lower latitudes with increasing magnetic and solar activity can explain the lack of correspondence between variations of spread-F occurrence as a function of magnetic activity at sunspot maximum compared with that at sunspot minimum at Argentine Islands.     

Equatorwards limits of the southern scintillation oval

Radio signals in the VHF range were recorded and compared with ionograms over a wide range of southern latitudes during a few equinoctial months for which a large variation in the magnetic disturbance level was observed. It is evident that the equatorwards edge of the auroral scintillation oval extends well into mid-latitudes for high values of magnetic K-index. The range-spreading type of spread-F and scintillation-producing irregularities show a high degree of spatial coincidence from the polar cap to mid-latitudes. It is suggested that the inhomogeneities responsible for both ionospheric phenomena are associated with the equatorwards propagation of travelling ionospheric disturbances (T1Ds) generated in the auroral zone.     

Analysis of Es traces from a calibrated oblique ionosonde

An analysis is performed on ionosonde data produced during five years of operation of an oblique sounder transmitting on a path from Darwin (12.4°S, 130.9°E) to Alice Springs (23.5°S, 133.7°E). It is found that the occurrence of sporadic-E (E_s) shows a relatively mild diurnal dependence, with a significant amount of E_s occurring in the early evening before midnight. It appears that, on average, nighttime E_s produces weaker reflections than daytime E_s.The power of the E_s reflections as a function of frequency is collated for all ionograms. The resulting power curve exhibits total and partial reflection sections. In trying to reproduce the partial reflection section of the curve it is shown that a layer without horizontal structure is required to be only 100 m thick. A second model involving a layer consisting of horizontally localised clouds of scatterers, with scale sizes ranging from 100 to 1000 metres, reproduces the partial reflection section of the curve quite well. The size, intensity and distribution of the clouds affects the curve shape on individual ionograms, resulting in the suggestion that nighttime layers are more irregular than daytime layers.     

A study of gravity waves in ionospheric electron content at L = 4

Using satellite radio beacon transmissions, travelling ionospheric disturbances have been observed in the electron content at L = 4. Waves are a common feature at this latitude, present for at least 98% of all daylight hours. The amplitude is usually 1–4% of the mean electron content and periods range between 15 and 90 minutes. Simultaneous observation of two satellite beacons, giving an effective east-west separation of 350 km, indicated apparent east-to-west velocities of 200–700 m/s.A search was made for a likely source of the waves, using data from magnetometers and riometers, from incoherent scatter radar measurements of Joule heating, and from orbiting satellite measurements of electron influx, but no definite source could be established.It is also shown that travelling disturbances are closely related to occurrences of spread-F on ionograms at high latitudes.     

Amplitude statistics of signals reflected from the ionosphere

Statistical analysis methods used to define the amplitude distributions of signals returned from the ionosphere are discussed in this paper. Emphasis is placed on determining accurately the parameter B, which is the ratio of steady to random components present in a signal. Thus B > 1 if the signal is dominated by the steady component, and B < 1 when the random components dominate. This study investigates the characteristics of B for F-region and E-region ionospheric echoes, as well as some types of spread-F, observed at the southern mid-latitude station Beveridge (37.3 S and 144.6 E). The results indicate that amplitude measurements obtained in approximately 100 s are adequate for determining B. The results also illustrate some effects that the E-region can have on F-region echoes.It is found that frequency spreading, the most common type of spreading observed at Beveridge, displays strong specular reflections and some signal variation due to interference at the leading edge of the F-region echo (i.e. B > 2). Within the spread echo B fluctuates between 0 and about 1.5 but is typically less than 1. The autocorrelation function of signal amplitude has a relatively large coherence interval, suggesting that this type of spread-F is due to interference of specular reflections from coherent irregularity structures with horizontal scale sizes of tens of kilometres rather than scattering from small scale irregularities. A second form of spread-F which would generally be classified as frequency spreading on standard ionoerams is actually due to off-vertical reflections from patches ol irregularities which originate south (poleward) of Beveridge. Echoes within this oblique spread-F (OS-F) do not exhibit coherence indicating that the irregularities responsible are of a smaller scale than those producing normal frequency spread. Finally, the phenomenon of spreading occurring on the second hop, but not the first hop trace is studied. It is shown that the form of the second hop echoes can be reproduced using a simple geometric model of ground scatter. The interpretation is supported by the fact that B for spread second hop echoes is less than 1 whereas it is much greater than 1 for the corresponding first hop echoes.     

MF and HF ducting within equatorial bubbles

MF and HF conjugate ducting is often observed while satellite sounders are within equatorial bubbles. This paper examines two possible forms of this propagation. The first is guiding by the bubble itself, the second is ducting along irregularities, of small cross-section, embedded in the bubble. One bubble model, based on observations by Dyson and Benson [Geophys. Res. Lett. 9, 795 (1978)], gives some results at variance with observation. Nevertheless it is considered that slight changes to the model, such as asymmetries between the conjugate ionospheres, should remove the discrepancies. The results show that bubbles themselves will definitely produce conjugate ducting on occasions. The alternative explanation requires ducts of small cross-section, distributed throughout the bubble in order to produce conjugate ducting on successive ionograms. Good matches between calculated and observed echo traces for conjugate echoes were obtained using this model. It is likely that both forms of propagation occur.     

Characteristics of ionospheric irregularities capable of producing quasi-horizontal traces on ionograms

This paper presents simulated ionograms calculated for a parabolic ionospheric layer containing irregularities in the form of small amplitude waves. With small amplitudes, perturbation techniques can be used enabling results for the irregular ionospheres to be calculated from the results for smooth ionospheres. This approach is relatively straightforward and avoids having to ray trace new paths each time the irregularity parameters are changed. It is, however, restricted to irregularities which do not cause multiple echoes. Irregularities with vertical wavelengths of up to a few kilometres can produce significant changes in the ionosphere over height intervals smaller than those involved in reflecting a single pulse. Consequently, in the simulation procedure, it is essential to consider not just the carrier frequency but the complete frequency spectrum of the pulse. Irregularities with vertical wavelengths of the order of 10 km or more can produce ripples in an ionogram trace. These will, of course, be more evident on ionograms with high frequency resolution. Irregularities with vertical wavelengths of up to several kilometres and amplitudes up to a few per cent can produce significant pulse spreading and splitting. The actual effects depend not just on the irregularity properties but also on the ionosonde pulse width, gain and frequency and height resolutions. Some simulations show trace splitting and quasi-horizontal traces similar in many respects to effects observed by Bowman (1987, J. atmos. terr. Phys. 49, 1007) and Bowmanet al. (1988, J. atmos. terr. Phys. 50, 797). Consequently it is suggested that, at least in some cases, small amplitude (≤3%) and small scale (≤4 km) irregularities produce the spread-ifF reported by these authors.     

The classification of distorted-mirror reflections and its ionospheric modification due to the underlying ionization

A systematic classification of reflections from a sinusoidally distorted-mirror has led to the identification of three classes of rays: direct simple rays which hit the mirror once on reflection; direct complex rays which hit the mirror several times before reflection; indirect rays which leave from and return to the source at different angles. The conditions on the distortion amplitude, wavelength and height for the different classes to exist are obtained. A comparison of results is made with those from a Chapman layer with a sinusoidally varying height of peak density, in the absence of any magnetic field. The broad classification of solutions is preserved, but direct and indirect rays are no longer independent and at large scale heights the presence of underlying ionization removes some solutions. The construction of ionograms of these profiles shows that indirect and complex direct rays contribute significantly to the traces observed.     

HF observations of the vertical structure of mid-latitude spread-Es

The Bribie Island HF radar array (27°S, 153° E) can be set up to make angle of arrival and Doppler shift measurements throughout the range of spread-E_s, layers. Results of this experiment show that the range spread seen on ionograms is not due to multiple reflection with varying obliquity, but rather a genuine height spread exists. Where velocity measurements can be reliably made, reflector velocity appears to be a slowly varying function of height. Spread-E_s, can be blanketing or non-blanketing, sequential or non-sequential and at first impression it seems that the chief difference between spread-E_s, and normal E_s, is a small scale, partially transparent structure in lower regions that allows higher regions to be observed. It is suggested that on occasion spread-E_s, irregularities are further modulated by the passage of gravity waves.     

Spread-Es structure producing apparent small scale structure in the F-region

When transmitting on 5.8 MHz the Bribie Island HF radar array synthesizes a beam that is 2.5 wide. The beam can be steered rapidly across the sky or left to dwell in any direction to observe the fading rates of echoes within a small cone of angles. With the beam held stationary, the time scale associated with deep fading of F-region echoes is usually more than 5 min. This is consistent with the focusing and defocusing effects caused by the passage of ever-present medium-scale travelling ionospheric disturbances (TIDs). On occasion the time scale for deep fading is much shorter, of the order of tens of seconds or less, and this is thought to be due to the interference of many echoes from within the beam of the radar. It is shown that the echoes are not due to scatter from fine structure in the F-region, but rather due to the creation of multiple F-region paths with differing phase lengths by small, refracting irregularities in underlying, transparent spread sporadic-E, (Spread-E_s). The natural drift of the Spread-E_s causes the phase paths of the different echoes to change in different ways causing the interference.Two methods are used to investigate the rapidly fading F-region signals. Doppler sorting of the refracted F-region signal does not resolve echoes in angle of arrival suggesting that many echoes exist within a Fresnel zone [Whitehead and Monro (1975), J. atmos. terr. Phys. 37, 1427]. Statistical analysis of F-region amplitude data indicates that when the range spread in E_s is severe on ionograms, then a modified Rayleigh distribution caused by the combination of 10 or so echoes is most appropriate. Using knowledge of the refracting process the scale of E_s structure is deduced from these results. Both methods find a Spread-E_s irregularity size of the order of 1 km or less. It is proposed that the Rayleigh type F-region signals seen by Jacobsonet al. [(1991b), J. atmos. terr. Phys. 53, 63] are F-region signals refracted by spread-E_s.     

Recent progress in transequatorial propagation—review

Transequatorial propagation of HF and VHF radio waves is placed into three categories according to the physical mechanisms. Specular reflection off the underside of the anomalously dense equatorial F-layer is predictable by ray tracing and limited to frequencies less than about 60 MHz. Multipoint reflection from bottomside irregularities applies for the same radio frequencies but is associated with travelling ionospheric disturbances and spread-F traces on ionograms. This type of TEP may be used as a technique for studying some of the properties of bottomside irregularities. Ducted propagation of VHF waves depends upon high plasma density gradients and occurs along equatorial plasma bubbles during the evening hours. Observations on the ducted VHF mode relate to the behaviour of plasma bubbles.     

Electron density profiles over the Southern Ocean from oblique incidence ionograms

This paper presents a first attempt to use oblique incidence ionograms over the 4500 km path from Sanae, Antarctica, to Grahamstown, South Africa, to deduce information about the ionosphere in the intervening regions. It is shown that existing methods for the reduction of oblique incidence ionograms to N(h) profiles give reasonable results even over the two-hop path involved. By comparison with vertical incidence ionograms made from a research ship below the reflection regions it is shown that the maximum observed frequency is normally limited by conditions at the southernmost reflection point, though this may be modified by ionospheric tilts, sunrise and sunset.     

Anomalous multiple traces below foE in high gain ionograms recorded at Sodankylä

Anomalous multiple trace patterns below f_oE have been observed in the high gain ionograms recorded at Sodankylä (67°22' N, 26°38' E). The patterns normally contain 3–6 traces with a virtual height separation of 50–80 km. A relationship between the daily variations of the occurrence of the multiples and the high type sporadic E-layers has been found. Model calculations are presented and it is concluded that the phenomenon is caused by multiple transits of z-mode radio pulses between a semitransparent sporadic E-layer and the lower F-region.     

Angular characteristics of radio pulses reflected from the subpolar ionosphere

This paper presents the results derived by measuring angular spectra of HF-radio pulses reflected from the subpolar ionospheric F2-region (62°N) using vertical-incidence soundings and a phase direction finder with Doppler filtering. The results correspond to three main types. One is the classical mirror reflection from the undisturbed ionospheric F2-region, typical of mid-latitudes (deviations from zenith do not exceed 3°; the angular spectrum width is less than 1°). The second type includes oblique diffuse reflections with a deviation from zenith of from 10 to 45°. The azimuth of arrival of these reflections is distributed in the range from 0 to 360°, the angular spectrum width is from 5 to 10°, and the range varies from 400 to 600 km. The third type includes anomalous mirror reflections with small deviations from zenith (not greater than 3°) but with substantially larger detection ranges (for example, 500km) as compared with the main reflections (250–300 km).     

Inversion of oblique ionograms including the Earth's magnetic field

A technique for determining ionospheric electron distribution from oblique ionograms is presented, based on the inversion method of Reilly and Kolesar (Radio Sci. 24, 575, 1989). It makes use of an equivalent operating frequency and an additional term to account for magnetoionic effects associated with the Earth's magnetic field. The technique is demonstrated by application to synthetic oblique ionograms, and to an experimentally obtained ionogram.